Fluency:

  • Asilbek - struggles
  • Shirin - very good
  • Robiya - struggles more than Asilbek

Pronunciation:

  • Asilbek - good, makes mistakes
  • Shirin - very good, but still mispronounces some words like nervous
  • Robiya - good, makes a few mistakes

Vocabulary:

  • Asilbek - good
  • Shirin - very good
  • Robiya - weak, she doesn’t know or can’t remember many words

Active/Passive:

  • Asilbek - active
  • Shirin - very active
  • Robiya - not so active

Open to speak:

  • Asilbek - very open, he can start
  • Shirin - yes, but only when she knows
  • Robiya - no

Who gets easily:

  • Asilbek - no, not often
  • Shirin - hardly ever, sometimes very fast
  • Robiya - a bit slow, so often

Observation for development - describe before you interpret · One-to-one-in-a-group - stop rubberstamping answers · Topic - Teacher Development